Last seen: June 11, 2002
On a warm summer afternoon in 2002, 17-year-old Bethany Cruz vanished during a family picnic at the Beaver Creek Picnic Area near Payson, Arizona. Bethany, a high school senior with plans to attend Arizona State University in the fall, had joined her extended family for a weekend outing in the forest.
Around 2:30 PM, Bethany was seen walking alone toward the creek, reportedly saying she needed a moment to herself. Several people remember seeing her along the trail, waving or smiling, but she never returned.
Her family searched for her for nearly an hour before alerting authorities. That evening, police, forest rangers, and local volunteers began combing the area. Search dogs traced her scent to a flat rock along the creek, but the trail ended there.
Divers searched the water. Drones scanned the woods. Despite exhaustive efforts over the next two weeks, no trace of Bethany, her clothes, or belongings was found. It was as if she had stepped off the rock and vanished into thin air.
While some believe she slipped and drowned, the lack of any physical evidence challenged that conclusion. Others suggested she may have run away, though her packed bag, wallet, and phone were still at the picnic site. A few speculated about strangers in the area that day.
Bethany’s mother, Rosa Cruz, returned to the creek every year on June 11th with flowers and a hope that someday her daughter might return. "We never stopped looking," she said in a 2012 interview. "We never will."
Page last updated: February 2016
Return to Home